Celebrity Justice
Anna Nicole to E!: You Screwed Me

The new E! show "Pop Fiction" sounds like a complete rip off of another pitch -- "Celebrities Strike Back." Oh, by the way -- it was pitched by Anna Nicole Smith more than three years ago and there could be a lawsuit.
Read the treatment
"Pop Fiction," produced by Ashton Kutcher's Katalyst Television, debuted last night. It seems identical to a treatment obtained by TMZ that Anna Nicole registered with the Writers Guild in 2004. Now get this -- in 2004, Anna Nicole and Howard K. Stern met with Jeff Shore and Jay James, both programming execs for E!. They pitched the show and sent Shore the treatment.

We're also told Anna Nicole and Howard K. met with then E! Prez Ted Harbert in 2004 and also raised the show.

Ashton's show sounds like a carbon of Anna's treatment -- "...what happens if Anna Nicole Smith and other celebrities turn the tables and capitalize off of the overzealous media? What if the next big supposed scandal is not a scandal at all? What if everything is staged, but the media (and the public) don't know it?" It continues, Anna Nicole and other celebrity guests take aim at the media and push all the limits."

That's Ashton Kutcher's show and we're told Howard K. has already threatened suit. What is really pissing him off is that he and Anna had multiple meetings with E!. Two months ago, Stern spoke with E! again on behalf of the estate and the network seemed intrigued by making Larry Birkhead the celeb to do the first prank and then host the show. Ultimately Jay James said it just wouldn't work. Oh really?

UPDATE: A rep for E! tells us, "'Pop Fiction' is a program independently created and developed by Ashton Kutcher's company, Katalyst. 'Pop Fiction' is not based on any idea or concept that may have been pitched to E! by any other party."

Reader Comments

(Page 9 of 10) Previous 15 Comments | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

121. what is it with you people??? why all about this howard, when its ashton k. & "E" doing this.

i like what the one person said on here & is very ture.........ITS THE FANS WHO PAY THESE STARS SO MUCH MONEY,WE HAVE THE RIGHT TO HAVE PAP'S.....STAY THE FRIG HOME IF YOU DONT WANT YOUR PIC TAKEN, YOU HAVE THE MONEY TO HAVE THINGS DELIVERED & I BET MOST HAVE BACKYARDS LIKE PARADISE.

to maureen: why you worried about spelling on here? if you noticed its not easy typing on tmz, this site has problems playing their videos too!

omg! did i spell everything right for you??
GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO howard & sue

Posted at 11:20AM on Mar 11th 2008 by MODsame age as me

122. next show is avil lavine,faking pregnancy.................

Posted at 11:22AM on Mar 11th 2008 by fake bump

123. Hi Kikoke – agree with everything you posted. It is good to see Walter Barbera and Sarah (minus her issues) here and we know the rest of our group of concerned citizens are still here too, if only in spirit, while we all wait for the Inquest to resume and hopefully resolve some issues on behalf of Daniel.

Shout out to blonde2thebone, Diego Chick, Ashlee, HomGrl, and BamaBabe. We all want justice for Daniel and eventually Anna and Dannielynn. We believe that justice for them, includes support for Mrs. Virgie Arthur.

Let’s leave this stupid story about the E! program … and go back to the Inquest blog, where our main concern will always be.

http://www.tmz.com/2008/01/30/daniel-smith-inquest-back-in-session/12#comments



Posted at 11:58AM on Mar 11th 2008 by Inquiring Mind

124. Testing the market


This article here at TMZ about a possible TV show starring LB is nothing more than part of a marketing technique to see how receptive an audience might be to the idea.

Sad to say, but WE are the test market. Market indicators say that WE are the "typical" audience that would watch such a show.

Well, I hope the analysts are getting the idea. About 1% of the comments here reflect that a show hosted by LB might work.

On the other hand, 99% of the posts say that anything associated with Howard K. Stern is a bad idea.

The results on TMZ do not automatically preclude the development of some kind of television show. Instead, it can be used to inform HOW TO PROMOTE the program, how to develop the show, etc., to make it more palatable to the public.

Just keep this in mind: The appearance of this article on TMZ is no happenstance event. This is part of a carefully crafted campaign dreamed up when Stern and Birkhead talked privately just before Stern dropped out of the DNA race.

Some of us were able to predict all this.



Posted at 12:19PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER

125. Boy, show biz sure is sleazy.

Posted at 2:34AM on Mar 11th 2008 by FYI
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You said it!


Posted at 1:30PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER

126. Yes,..."E" Network is most certainly guilty of piracy,...however no one can blame them for not wanting to link themselves to individuals such as Howard K. $tern.
The issues surrounding the networks hestitation to seal any deal regarding future show formats had purely to do with the involvement of Howard K. $tern,...not Anna Nicole.
A deal with the likes of $tern would be foolish on anyones part,...and nobody likes to loose money rather than make it do they?
Anna Nicole was never the issue,...$tern was,...he convinced Anna that he was the only one able to resurrect her lagging career and she most certainly paid the ultimate price for beleiving what he said to be true.

Posted at 1:17PM on Mar 11th 2008 by TRUTH

127. Posted at 12:19PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER


Another well written post. Do you ever stop? Here you are, at it again...lol....

Thanks for the read...

Posted at 1:26PM on Mar 11th 2008 by uuuhhooohh!!!

128. 127. Posted at 12:19PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER


Another well written post. Do you ever stop? Here you are, at it again...lol....

Thanks for the read...

Posted at 1:26PM on Mar 11th 2008 by uuuhhooohh!!!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Hi Uh-Oh!

You're one of my favorite posters! I'm glad to see your moniker again!




Posted at 1:32PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER

129. Posted at 1:32PM on Mar 11th 2008 by EGO BUSTER

Just popped in for a peek at the latest, can't stick around...can't wait till we FINALLY see some resolution...good to see you, too...I'll be back....again and again, hoping for JUSTICE...TC.

Posted at 1:37PM on Mar 11th 2008 by uuuhhooohh!!!

130. anna is dead, daniel is dead. One person was present at both deaths. that very same person is still alive. explain that to the best of anyone's ability. how does that happen? has anyone who has been posting all these months ever sat by while someone accidentally died of a drug overdose? well, if you did that once, did you do it again? BTW, did you have the murder weapons in your name?.......did you even try to help them not die? hmmm...that's what I thought..

Posted at 2:49PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Frustrated beyond belief..

Posted at 2:59PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Frustrated beyond belief ..

Posted at 3:03PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Frustrated beyond belief..

131. Birkhead is the new Anna Nicole? How funny! Howard & Larry are the two most disliked people in the world & NO ONE, EXCEPT THEIR NUTTY FOLLOWERS, would ever watch any show they are on.

Posted at 4:25PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Princess

132. Howard, did you claim the rights to Anna's farts also?

Posted at 12:52AM on Mar 12th 2008 by wouldn't doubt it

133. HK$...BOW OUT GRACEFULLY!!!!...Understand that ANS ONLY LOVED ANS...IMO she was FAKE in everything that she did...ESPECIALLY CHEATING ON J.HOWARD MARSHALL who she only married for his money.....
Be very very carefull HK$...you supplied the drugs to both ANS & Daniel...THAT MAKES YOU AN "ENABLER"....
Personally I hope that you are charged with NEGLIGENCE {at least} !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 1:29AM on Mar 12th 2008 by Jill from Western Australia

134. E! seems to be trying to clear up any rumors that it's newest show Pop Fiction wasn't an original idea from professional pranker Ashton Kutcher, but that it was in fact stolen from, none other than, Anna Nicole Smith.

It's been reported that over three years ago, Anna Nicole and her crew, including Howard K. Stern, pitched the show to E! and even registered the idea with the Writer's Guild. E! ultimately decided the show wouldn't work.

Cut to Pop Fictions's premiere this past Sunday. The show's concept, which uses celebs to make up fake news items to see if the media will run them, is almost identical to the one that Anna Nicole came up with. Today E! released a statement to OK! maintaining that the show is all original to Ashton.

They said, "Pop Fiction is a program independently created and developed by Ashton Kutcher's company, Katalyst. Pop Fiction is not based on any idea or concept that may have been pitched to E! by any other party."

http://www.okmagazine.com/news/view/5145

Posted at 1:52PM on Mar 12th 2008 by Ok!!

135. The police should ATREEST HOWARD K STERN & LARRY BIRKHEAD!!! THESE BUMS WILL SUE EVERYONE TO GET A BUCK!!! GET A REAL JOB YOU BUMS & QUIT LIVING OFF OF OTHERS PEOPLES MONEY!!!

Posted at 1:44PM on Mar 12th 2008 by Cheryl Soto

Previous 15 Comments | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments